A Masterpiece
Very few games are worthy of all 10 stars, this is true. But this one is.
The first Punk-O-Matic was a surprise hit, with fun-to-create songs and unusual comedy. But there was something lacking, and after a while the riffs got old. Still, the fanbase held strong and worshiped the game like nothing else on Newgrounds.
When this game arrived in January, there was a big split in the fanbase -- what was this "story mode" shit? Guitar Hero-esque performances, what? -- but those who were open-minded enough to try out this new game would be pleasantly surprised, if not completely blown away.
The 31 riffs in the original game are here, but have been recreated AND expanded upon greatly -- any kind of riff or chord you can think of, you can create in this game (including ska/reggae chords). Plus a bass guitar has been added into the mix, leading to a much fuller sound. Solos, breakdowns, melodies, and the like are all now able to be inserted into your song.
Unlike the first game, you don't stop at creating songs and watching your band play; there's a full on story mode, where you have to perform your songs a la Guitar Hero or Rock Band. Game secrets and cash are your reward, and your able to spend your cash on new gear for your band. Customization? Forget about it -- and best of all, you can choose NOT to play story mode and simply revel in your own punk-rock-metal dress-up.
If there is a weak point in this game, it is the humor -- when you first play it, the cut-scenes feel all too serious. Turns out, the first game's marijuana humor is supposed to be the main focus, but only *subtly so.* Still, if that's the only fault in your games, good job -- better than any other game out now.
With the first game, Evil-Dog seemed eager, raw, ready to prove himself to the world. With the sequel, he's more than done that. This is his masterpiece and should be a Newgrounds classic for years to come. The game engine is unlike any other for a Flash-based game, and the online support is sure to make many users shout out in glee (or disappointment). If there is a third game coming in the future, he has a lot to live up to.
But if the improvement over the first game is a sign, maybe Evil-Dog's up to the challenge.